Why the State of Israel? An Analytical Perspective on the Israeli-Arab Issue

Why the State of Israel? An Analytical Perspective on the Israeli-Arab Issue

Introduction: Facing Reality with Courage

The Israeli-Palestinian issue has always been a sensitive topic that fuels debates across political, religious, and intellectual circles. However, beyond emotions and populist rhetoric, we must analyze reality rationally and answer the question: Why the State of Israel?

Many argue that Israel’s creation was a historical anomaly, driven by colonial interests and religious, economic, and political pressures. However, today we are facing an undeniable reality—Israel is now a modern and advanced state, while Arab nations continue to struggle with backwardness and internal divisions.

This article aims to provide a balanced perspective on Israel’s right to exist, the Arab responsibility in its establishment, and the challenges facing the Palestinian cause.

1- Should the State of Israel Have Been Created?

From a moral standpoint, it can be argued that Israel was established at the expense of the Palestinian people, making it a clear colonial injustice. However, at the same time, we cannot ignore the responsibility of the Arabs themselves in this matter.

• Arab states were not unified in their stance, and instead of devising smart political solutions, they engaged in losing wars that only strengthened Israel.
• Many Arab leaders exploited the Palestinian cause for their own political interests, without providing real solutions.
• Divisions among Palestinians themselves weakened their international position.

That said, outright rejection of Israel or calls for its destruction are not realistic solutions. Such positions only perpetuate the same injustice that was inflicted upon the Palestinians, but this time against the Jewish people.

2- Do Jews Have the Right to Establish Their Own State?

The Jewish people are an integral part of the historical fabric of the Middle East and have a long history in the region. Denying their right to a state mirrors the same exclusionary mindset that Palestinians suffer from today.

From a historical rights perspective, Jews have a cultural, religious, and historical connection to the land of Palestine, just as Palestinians have their rightful claim to their homeland. The problem is not in Israel’s existence itself, but rather in how to resolve the conflict in a way that ensures justice for both parties.

The Possible Solution: Two Secular States

The only viable solution is the creation of two secular states based on human rights, where:

• Palestinians obtain an independent and sovereign state.
• Jews maintain Israel as their national homeland.
• Clearly defined and fair borders prevent future conflicts.

For this solution to be realized, both parties must abandon extremist religious ideologies and start thinking in terms of shared interests instead of exclusionary nationalism.

3- Why Has Israel Succeeded While Arab States Have Failed?

Whether we agree with it or not, Israel today is a successful modern state, while Arab nations suffer from dictatorship, underdevelopment, and internal conflicts.

What’s the Difference?

• In Israel, religion does not hinder progress; instead, it serves as a tool for maintaining identity without restricting personal freedoms.
• In the Arab world, religion dominates everything—politics, education, and social life—preventing any meaningful progress.
• Israel has skillfully capitalized on international opportunities, while Arabs have wasted time on pointless wars and empty nationalist rhetoric.

Israel’s Economic and Scientific Advancements

Israel is one of the most technologically advanced nations, excelling in medicine, research, and innovation, while Arab nations struggle with scientific stagnation and brain drain.

So, is the problem Israel itself? Or is it the Arab world’s failure to keep up with modern civilization?

As the Arab intellectual Abdullah Al-Qasimi once said:

“Israel is not big, we are small.”

4- Judaism and Pragmatic Thinking

If we examine the evolution of Judaism, we see that Jews have successfully adapted their religion to fit changing political and economic realities.

• Judaism is not a rigid belief system, but rather a flexible ideology that evolves with time.
• Jews realized early on that religion can be a political tool, not just a set of spiritual practices.
• They have largely separated religion from the state, allowing them to build a modern secular system.

On the other hand, Islam remains a major obstacle to progress in the Arab world because:

• Religion is used as a tool for suppressing freedoms.
• Any attempt to modernize or reform Islamic law is met with fierce resistance.
• Arab identity is tied to Islam, making it impossible to separate religion from national identity.

5- What Can Arabs Learn from Israel’s Experience?

Instead of blindly opposing Israel, why not focus on fixing our own societies?

• Separate religion from politics: The Arab world cannot progress as long as Islam controls political, economic, and intellectual life.
• Reform education: Arab nations need a radical transformation of their education systems to align with modern knowledge.
• Promote scientific research: Instead of wasting time on ideological conflicts, Arabs should invest in science and technology as Israel has done.
• Establish real democratic systems: Despite all criticisms, Israel provides political pluralism and freedom of speech, unlike most Arab countries.

Conclusion: Are We Ready to Face Reality?

Despite the injustice faced by Palestinians, we cannot deny Israel’s success as a modern state, nor can Arabs continue to blame others without addressing their own internal failures.

The future of the region depends on moving beyond narrow religious and nationalist ideologies and shifting towards pragmatic thinking that seeks mutual coexistence and shared progress.

Israel is not the real problem—the Arab world’s failure to modernize is.

If Arabs truly wish to regain their influence, they must learn from successful models instead of fighting them.

You can also read: Hatem Saïed… The Name That Must Not Be Spoken